Español

Security resources for home and online
Disclosure
Home > Home Security > Best Smoke Detector: Ionization, Photoelectric Or Dual Sensor?

Best Smoke Detector: Ionization, Photoelectric Or Dual Sensor?

Smoke detector with smokeThe U.S. Fire Administration (USFA) reported 1,448 residential fire fatalities between January 1 and July 31, 2013. The USFA gleans this information solely from U.S. news media reports, and estimates this number is about one third to one half of the actual residential fire fatalities occurring each year. We recently published an article titled Fire Safety Tips on how to prevent fires and stay safe around fire hazards. While we all try to do what we can to prevent residential fires, the easiest, most effective action we can take is to install smoke detectors in every room of our home.

A properly installed and maintained smoke detector is on alert 24 hours a day – whether you are awake or asleep – scanning for fire or smoke. The best smoke detectors are reliable, durable, and easy to test and maintain.

Types of Smoke Detectors

The two primary types of residential smoke detectors contain either ionization or photoelectric sensors. Each type of smoke alarm detects distinctly different types of fires, so dual sensor alarms, which utilize both types of sensors, have risen in popularity.

Smoke detectors consist of two basic parts: a sensor to sense smoke and a loud electronic alarm. They can run off of a 9-volt battery or be hardwired into a 120-volt house current. The batteries, or backup batteries in a hardwired system, should be tested on a regular basis and replaced at least once each year.

Additionally, some smoke alarms are designed to meet the needs of people with hearing disabilities. These alarms use strobe lights and vibrations to alert anyone unable to hear standard smoke detectors.

Ionization

Ionization smoke detectors contain a very small amount of americium-241 within an ionization chamber. They create an electric current between two metal plates, which sound an alarm when disrupted by smoke entering the chamber. Ionization smoke alarms can quickly detect the small amounts of smoke produced by fast flaming fires, such as cooking fires or fires fueled by paper or flammable liquids.

This type of smoke detector, which is commonly used in kitchens, is prone to nuisance tripping. For example, we’ve all experienced the loud annoying chirping when we leave a cake in the oven too long or add oil to an extremely hot pan. When this happens, people are more prone to disable the alarms.

 

Photoelectric

Photoelectric smoke detectors contain a light source in a light-sensitive electric sensor, which are positioned at 90-degree angles to one another. Normally, light from the light source shoots straight across and misses the sensor.  When smoke enters the chamber, it scatters the light, which then hits the sensor and triggers the alarm.

Photoelectric smoke detectors typically respond faster to a fire in its early, smoldering stage – before the source of the fire bursts into flames. These detectors are more sensitive to the large combustion particles that emanate during slow, smoldering fires, which usually occur at night when people are asleep.

 

Dual Sensor

Dual sensor smoke detectors include both ionization and photoelectric sensors, so they should adequately alert homeowners of a smoldering fire or a fire with active flames. Some safety organizations have previously recommended these smoke alarms, because they should cover a broad range of fires.

However, there are no industry standards for setting the individual sensor sensitivity in dual sensor alarms. This means that a dual sensor alarm could have a non-functional ionization sensor, but as long as the photoelectric sensor works, it still meets the national standards developed by Underwriters Laboratories (UL).

What Type Do You Have?

Most residences have smoke detectors installed before their inhabitants move in. To find out whether you have ionization, photoelectric, or dual sensor alarms, take the smoke alarm down from the ceiling or wall and inspect the back.

As mentioned previously, ionization smoke alarms all contain a trace amount of the radioactive material americium-241.  Every ionization alarm has a warning about this material on the back label. In addition, it may have the words “ionization alarm” somewhere on the label. Photoelectric smoke detectors have the word “photoelectric” or a capital letter P printed or embossed on either the front or back. Dual sensor alarms have similar indications on their labels.

Best Smoke Detector: Which One Should You Buy?

The International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) – the largest firefighters union in the U.S. and Canada – recommends photoelectric smoke detectors. During their 2008 conference, the IAFF adopted an official position recommending only photoelectric smoke alarms and stated that dual sensor alarms are no longer acceptable.

The technology used in ionization smoke detectors leads to a delayed warning in smoldering fires, which can lead to greater loss of life. Ionization detectors are also weaker in high airflow environments, so the delay may be even longer. Photoelectric smoke alarms are more effective at warning of smoke from smoldering fires and are less susceptible to nuisance alarms.

To be safe, the IAFF and other safety organizations recommend homeowners replace all ionization, dual sensor, and unknown alarms with photoelectric smoke alarms.

What to Know Before You Buy

Functional smoke detectors continuously scan the air for smoke and can significantly increase your chances of surviving otherwise deadly residential fire. It can also help save the lives of firefighters who would otherwise have to risk their lives by searching a burning home for residents.

Look for the following features when purchasing a new smoke detector:

  • Easy installation – Many battery operated detectors are easier to install than hardwired systems
  • Testing – This ensures the smoke alarm is functioning properly
  • Battery backup – Units function with or without electrical power
  • Silence or Hush feature – Silence button enables you to quickly deactivate the alarm
  • Warranty – The best smoke alarms have 5-10 year warranties
  • Package deals – Many retailers offer packages with 4-6 smoke detectors
  • Interconnected units – These alarms connect to each other within a home to provide residence-wide alerts

In addition, keep these tips in mind:

  • State or municipality regulations – Check with your local and state authorities to learn about any specific requirements
  • Carbon monoxide detectors – These might be necessary depending on your home’s heating source
  • Existing smoke detectors – Hardwired and battery operated detectors should be replaced with the same types
  • Replace all smoke detectors at the same time – Especially if you don’t know the age of your current detectors

According to recent data, almost two-thirds of residential fire casualties occurred in homes without properly functioning smoke alarms. Any smoke alarm that is 10 years old or older should be replaced regardless of type. If you moved into a pre-owned home and do not know the age of the existing smoke alarm, you should replace them immediately.

Source: Residential Fire Fatalities in the News

 

Our site's mission is to help consumers make more informed purchase decisions. This website accepts financial compensation from some of the companies mentioned which allows us to provide this free service to our readers. Compensation does not influence the rankings of products. More info on our disclosure page.

Sign up to Receive a Free Home Safety Checklist, and Monthly Security Tips & Reviews!


About Kimberly Alt
Kimberly has always taken security seriously. Whether it's making sure she locks all the doors or using complex passwords, she tries her best to live a secure life. She has years of experience with testing, reviewing, and writing about security systems. One of her favorite parts of her job is being able to inform consumers of the best security products available.
0 0 0
Previous:
Next:
  • Lia

    Of course, here is a link to the IAFF website: http://www.thewfsf.org/iaff .

    • kurious kitty

      Thanks Lia 🙂

  • Lia

    Yes, we referenced the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) – the largest firefighters union in the U.S. and Canada. They recommend photoelectric sensors.

  • masterinspector

    Instead of going for ‘smoke’ detection, why don’t you utilize heat-monitoring? Install heat-sensors and tie them to a central monitoring system and develop normal operating ‘range’ for each sensor…then have the central monitoring system send an ‘alert’ if any sensor detects an ‘out-of-range’ signal indicating an over-heating condition. Any associated aerosol suppression system could be both manually or automatically activated based on your pre-set operating parameters.

  • Lia

    Amah – did you look at the Kidde PI9010 Sensor Battery Operated Smoke Alarm that we mentioned in the article? This system has a dual sensor smoke alarm for both photoelectric & ionization and a 10 year battery. It also has an indicator LED and test feature. On Amazon it runs about $22.65: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0007G71U4/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B0007G71U4&linkCode=as2&tag=aseli0b-20&linkId=f6436677a17fdee57be135ab07ec8efb

  • Lia

    We don’t currently have the answer to this, but we’d love to hear if someone else in our ASL community does.

  • Hey Jody,

    Are you talking about an existing wired alarm system in your home? If so, which one do you have? That will help us narrow down what smoke detectors will integrate with your system.

    • threejs

      I have an existing wired system of 3 alarms that I would like to replace, because they’ve been there for over 10 yrs. I want to purchase 3 wired, interconnected alarms that are photoelectric (or duel), ideally with carbon monoxide included. I will also be purchasing two separate units to add to two bedrooms where there currently are no alarms; those two will not be wired or interconnected. I would love some quick advice on what model to purchase, especially for the wired, interconnected ones. Thanks so much!

      • In that case, we would suggest this BRK model found on Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0080I9TJ2/ref=as_li_qf_sp_asin_il_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B0080I9TJ2&linkCode=as2&tag=aseli0b-20&linkId=L3JDYVR7RGIMGK3T. It is hardwired and can interconnect with multiple devices. It is also photoelectric and senses both smoke and carbon monoxide. Plus it comes with very high ratings.

        • threejs

          Thank you! Do you have any thoughts about what model to buy for the two separate ones that will go in the bedrooms that will not be wired?

          • Depending on what you are looking for, there are several options. We have outlined out top picks in each category in this post: http://www.asecurelife.com/brk-vs-kidde-vs-first-alert-vs-nest/. You could also look into non-wired battery operated ones like this one: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00PC5S0PA/ref=as_li_qf_sp_asin_il_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B00PC5S0PA&linkCode=as2&tag=aseli0b-20&linkId=KR47ICQIW4LDTEAZ. This model would also be a good choice if you still were interested in photoelectric ones: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00SWT5FBA/ref=as_li_qf_sp_asin_il_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B00SWT5FBA&linkCode=as2&tag=aseli0b-20&linkId=YUBXUVJWMSP3BLKE

            • Neil Brookins

              Jen, your recommendation for KN-COSM-BA goes against the advice of the main article above which recommends photoelectric only. I do not recommend the KN-COSM-BA because its an ionization type detector and does NOT contain any photoelectric sensor. Your other recommendation “X-Sense DS51” is lacking interconnect and does not talk to you to differentiate between smoke versus CO. A better option is the First Alert SCO501 which like the ones you recommend is battery operated; not wired. And its interconnected wirelessly and talks to you so you can easily tell if the alert is smoke versus CO. The interconnect feature is useful if there is a fire in the basement and you are sleeping upstairs – you want the alarm upstairs to sound even though the smoke is only in the basement. Some people in a deep sleep may not wake up when the basement alarm sounds alone if they are upstairs.

          • Neil Brookins

            Threejs, you need three different models for your situation. The First Alert SC7010BV is a good choice for the hard wired. But only get two of those. The third hardwired unit should be First Alert AC10-500 (or SA521CN which is cheaper) which will bridge the alarm signal between the 3 hardwired and the 2 wireless in the bedrooms. Use the First Alert SCO501B2 in the rooms without wires. Also, in this configuration all five are interconnected – some wirelessly and others wired. Its the best option for your specific scenario. For older houses that are not hardwired at all, use the SCO501B2 in all rooms. For newer houses that have wires in all rooms, use SC7010BV in all rooms. For all electric houses without attached garage, and without any fireplace, use photoelectric models without the CO sensor. Each house is different, no one solution for all.

        • Neil Brookins

          I don’t like the SC7010B because it has no display that tells you the PPM concentration of CO. Instead, I recommend the SC7010BV which verbally tells you the CO concentration in PPM. The two models are about the same price. Another problem with SC7010B is that it beeps for both CO and smoke and many people can’t tell the difference between the two beep sounds. (4 beeps = CO vs. 3 beeps = smoke) Its possible that you hear beeps, look for smoke, don’t see smoke, decide that its a false smoke alarm and disconnect the battery/power and go back to sleep – not realizing that CO is invisible! This could be fatal! Instead, with the SC7010BV you are told verbally “Carbon monoxide detected! evacuate!” and are less likely to think its a false alarm for smoke. This difference could save lives.

    • amah sossy

      Hi Jen, please am looking for smoke detector alarm and i believe i can get help from you with the specifications.
      Wish to forward the specs to you.

      • Lia

        Hi Amah – I’d love to help you! What specs are you looking for? – Lia

  • You are correct! We have responded more in depth in your other comment. Thank you!

  • guest

    Fantastic article! We have a photoelectric smoke detector (part of a monitored Frontpoint home security system) that went off at 5am the other night. The rep from Rapid Response monitoring called us right away and was very helpful explaining that despite the lack of smoke or fire, combustible particles could be triggering the smoke detector.  

    The next morning we discovered that we had inadvertently left the basement door open a crack. If my wife hadn't pointed out that she noticed a "bonfire smell" the night before we probably wouldn't have put two and two together. Amazing (but also reassuring) how sensitive the photoelectric smoke detector is!

    • JD

      We were recently cooking in my kitchen and the next thing I know we have smoke everywhere! It was under control, but after all of the chaos I realized that our smoke detector right outside the kitchen never went off. I tested the batteries and they were working fine. This caused me to do some research on smoke detectors and I found this article. I can't believe this information is not more publicized! Great to see a comment that Photoelectic sensors are sensitive enough to pick up the bon fire outside due to the door being left open. I just purchased one, thanks!